Apple Pie, an all American dessert. Who has never made Apple Pie? Well me, until last week. I have never really been a pie person. I only ever ate pies when it was Grandmas homemade pies at Thanksgiving. Other than that, commercial pies always had the chemical packaged super sweet bland flavor that I didn't care for. (same for cakes, I'll get into that another time) Last week my grandmother and I decided to bake two pies in two different fashions to taste the difference. The main differences are apple variety, thickening agent, flour vs. tapioca. Then you have fom scratch crust vs storebought packaged crust. Making apple pie is time consuming yet simple.
Grandmas Old Fashioned Apple Pie vs. Apple Pie Americana
Grandmas Old Fashioned Apple PieBake time 50-60 minutes
Bake Temperature 400 Degrees Fahrenheit
Filling5-6 small-medium apples (4 Granny Smith 2 Macintosh)
1 tsp cinnamon
3/4 cup sugar
dash ground cloves(
pssst...dash =one quick shake of tinned spice container)
dash ground allspice
2 Tbs Flour
Juice of 1/2 small lemon
Pinch salt
2 Tbs butter for dotting
For Crust2 cups flour
1tsp salt
2/3 cup shortening
6Tbs cold water
In large bowl combine flour and salt. Cut shortening either using a pastry blender, two knives or pulse with a food processor.(For these techniques see
***Pastry Methods) Combine until the shortening is pea sized lumps or smaller. Add water one tbs at a time until it starts to combine.
Hand form into two round balls. Press down on each ball to have a flat round mound. Tightly wrap in plastic wrap or zip top bag to store each half in refrigerator for at least an hour. When thoroughly chilled, one at a time place pastry on a floured surface and roll out to fit 9"pie plate. Set one aside for top.
***Pastry Methods
Pastry Blender-
$3.00 and up kitchen supply stores. a kitchen tool with several wires bent in a half moon shape connected by a handle used for making pastry! If you have this tool use it in a rocking motion and literally cut the fat into pieces while combining the flour.
Two Butter Knife Method-
Free in your cutlery drawer! Using two butter knives literally cut the fat into pieces while combining the flour. This method is the slowest but is good for the frugal cook who doesn't want any gadgets collecting dust between uses!
Food Processor- $50 and up kitchen supply stores. If you have this pricey multi talented appliance, use it whenever you have the chance to. Food processor makes this an easy task. Unless you don't have a dishwasher. Pulse flour salt and fat until pea like consistency pulse while adding cold water. Be careful not to over pulse or turn on full blast. This may turn your pastry into shortbread!
Filling-
Step 1. Peel, core and thinly slice apples. In a large bowl add apples sugar, salt spices, lemon juice and 2Tbs flour. Should be a more dry
grainy consistency. If soupy then you may need to add another apple.
Step 2. Pour apple mixture into prepared pie dish. 2Tbs butter cut into several small pieces and dot the filling. Top With second crust. Tuck the top crust 1/8" under bottom crust. Then using Thumbs and forefingers pinch the crust edges to finish.
On the top of the crust you may use a cookie cutter to cut out a shape or using a paring knife slice out a 1/2" circle in the center and use a fork to create vents. very important because the pie filling will bubble. Before its journey to the oven make sure to line the crust edges with foil to prevent burning. You may also brush melted butter on top to ensure a golden crust. Place a cookie sheet on middle rack of oven. Put pie on that sheet and bake for 40 minutes then remove foil to finish off baking. Allow pie to cool completely before serving. At least 2 hours.
Results: 5out out of 5 This pie came out decadent. I especially enjoyed the mix of apples, it added a complexity of apple flavor and texture. The filling produced a caramel like color and consistency and the apples were super tender. The pie crust was perfect contrast to the sweet filling. This is how I remember Thanksgiving!
Apple Pie AmericanaBake Time: 45-55 minutes
Bake Temperature: 400 Degrees Fahrenheit
Filling
5-6 Medium Granny Smith Apples
3/4 Cup Sugar
2 Tbs Quick Cooking Tapioca
1 tsp Ground Cinnamon
1/4 tsp ground nutmeg
2Tbs butter cut into pieces
CrustPackaged prepared crusts like Pillsbury brand Line 9" pie plate with one set aside other
FillingStep 1 Peel core and thinly slice the apples. In a large bowl toss the fruit with sugar spices tapioca. Line a Pie plate with one of the prepared crusts.
Follow step 2 of first pie here.
Results: 3.5 out of 5 stars! Surprisingly the prepackaged pie crusts were perfect.They were simple and resulted in less dishes.They tasted homemade without the work. The filling had a slightly sticky consistency, almost pasty. The apples were tender but it seems that the tapioca almost coated the apples and prevented them to fully absorb its full pie potential. Other than the texture, this pie lacked the deep velvety Carmel texture that grandmas had.
Lessons Learned:
Pastry Blending Tools and Methods
Difference in thickening agents for fruit fillings
Prepared Crust vs. Homemade